Remembering Amy

Amy Emily Annamunthodo was four years old. Her short life contained far more pain than any child should ever have known. But there was also a period in Amy's life that showed what could happen when she was finally placed somewhere safe. After years of concerns about abuse and repeated injuries, Amy was eventually admitted to the Mother's Union Children's Home in September 2005. There, away from the home in which she had been suffering, Amy reportedly began to improve. She was cared for. She was safe. And for a time, it appeared that Amy might finally have the opportunity every child deserves to grow up without being afraid. But in January 2006, a court ordered that Amy be released back into her mother's care. Less than four months later, she was dead.

Amy's Story

Concerns about Amy's safety existed years before her death. In March 2004, neighbors reportedly contacted police with allegations that Amy was being beaten and tortured. The following month, two year old Amy was taken to the hospital with a fractured arm. Medical examinations documented injuries of different ages across her face, back, arms, legs and buttocks. She also had swollen lips, an infected toe and fractures to the bones of her right forearm. Amy survived those injuries, but she was returned home. As Amy grew older, concerns continued. She was hospitalized again with numerous scars across her face and torso in different stages of healing, along with a large fluid filled swelling on her back consistent with trauma. In August 2005, police found Amy abandoned and she was again taken for medical care. By this point, her small body carried numerous scars and evidence of previous injuries. On September 5, 2005, Amy was admitted to the Mother's Union Children's Home. For a time, Amy was away from the environment in which she had repeatedly been hurt. Reports about her time at the children's home indicated that she began to improve while in care. But Amy's mother and grandmother sought to have her returned. On January 12, 2006, a court ordered that Amy be released back into her mother's care. Four months later, Amy was dead.

The Final Assault

On May 15, 2006, Amy suffered the violence that ended her life. Evidence presented during the criminal proceedings described an extraordinarily brutal assault. A witness testified that he saw Amy suspended by her hair, with a cloth tied to her hair and attached above her. According to his testimony, Marlon King punched the four year old approximately 20 to 30 times while she hung there. Amy's mouth was gagged. The injuries documented on Amy's body showed the severity of what she had endured. Amy had cigarette burns on her chest, forearm, thigh and genital area. She suffered a fractured rib and bruising across her chest, abdomen, back, buttocks, shoulder and hand. Internally, the damage was catastrophic. There was bleeding involving her heart and lungs and injuries to multiple organs, including her liver, spleen and kidneys. The violence inflicted upon Amy was so severe that her heart ruptured. Medical evidence presented in court determined that Amy died from multiple traumatic injuries caused by external force. Amy was taken to San Fernando General Hospital, but she was already dead. She had turned four years old only eight days earlier.

Warning Signs & System Failures

Amy's death is particularly devastating because the abuse she suffered had not remained completely hidden. People had noticed. Neighbors had reported concerns. Police had been involved. Doctors had treated Amy for serious injuries. Medical professionals had seen broken bones, bruises, scars and injuries in different stages of healing. Amy had been hospitalized more than once. Eventually, Amy was removed from the environment where she had been repeatedly hurt and placed in the Mother's Union Children's Home. There, reports indicated that she began to improve. She had reached a place of safety. But in January 2006, Amy was released back into her mother's care. Four months later, she was dead. Amy's death later became the subject of serious examination of the systems that had encountered her during her short life. Questions were raised about how a little girl with such a documented history of injuries could repeatedly come into contact with adults and institutions responsible for protecting children and still ultimately return to the environment where she would die.,There was another failure after Amy's death. Her mother, Anita Annamunthodo, was charged with child neglect and spent approximately 11 months incarcerated while the case was pending. In April 2007, the case collapsed. Contemporary reporting described repeated failures by the police complainant to appear in court, the absence of a prosecution file before the Director of Public Prosecutions, and the failure of State witnesses to appear. The magistrate ultimately discharged the case against her. Amy had been seen. Her injuries had been documented. Concerns had been reported. She had been hospitalized. She had even reached a place where she was reportedly doing better. And still, Amy was returned to the environment where she ultimately died. Amy was four years old. Protecting herself was never supposed to be her responsibility. The adults and systems surrounding her had that responsibility. She deserved for someone to make sure she remained safe while there was still time.

Justice for Amy

Marlon King was charged with Amy's murder. After a lengthy trial, on March 1, 2012, a jury found him guilty. He was sentenced to death.  For years, Amy's case appeared to have reached its conclusion. It hadn't. King appealed. In 2021, Trinidad and Tobago's Court of Appeal overturned his murder conviction and death sentence after finding errors in the way the trial had been conducted. Importantly, overturning the conviction did not amount to a judicial finding that King was innocent. The Court ordered that he be tried again.  A second trial eventually took place in 2025. After hearing the case, the jury deliberated but could not reach a verdict. The result was a hung jury. In September 2025, the court ordered that Marlon King face a third murder trial for Amy's death. 

​

Accused: Marlon King

Relationship to Amy: Mother's common law partner/stepfather

2012: Convicted of murder and sentenced to death

2021: Conviction and sentence overturned on appeal; retrial ordered

2025: Second trial ended with a hung jury

​

Current status: Third murder trial ordered

Forever Remembered

There are many dates in Amy's story when something different could have happened. When neighbors reported concerns. When doctors treated her broken arm. When medical professionals saw injuries of different ages. When Amy returned to the hospital covered in scars. When she was finally placed in a children's home. When she began doing better there. And when the decision was made to send her home. It is impossible to know the person Amy would have become. But we know she deserved the chance to find out. Amy Annamunthodo was four years old. She deserved birthdays beyond her fourth. She deserved school, friendships, laughter and ordinary childhood memories. She deserved for the adults who saw her injuries to make sure she never had to return to the place where she was being hurt. Her case has moved through the courts for nearly two decades, and its legal outcome has changed more than once. But one thing has never changed: Amy mattered. Abuse Angels remembers Amy, tells the truth about what happened to her, and remembers the four year old girl behind a case that is still seeking its final legal conclusion.

Amy Emily Annamunthodo mattered. And she will never be forgotten.