Ethan Thomas Henderson

February 21, 2012 – May 8, 2012

 

Age: 11 Weeks

Location: Portland, Maine

Suspect in death: Gordon Collins-Faunce, Father

Ethan Henderson

REMEMBERING ETHAN

Ethan Thomas Henderson lived for less than three months. He was born on February 21, 2012, in Portland, Maine, the son of Christina Henderson and Gordon Collins-Faunce.

Ethan had a twin brother named Lucas and an older sister. His mother called him her “cuddle bug.”

That small description gives us something the court records cannot. Before Ethan became the subject of investigations, medical reviews, and a criminal prosecution, he was a baby who was held and cuddled by people who loved him.

He had blue eyes and wispy blond hair. He had a twin brother who should have grown beside him.

There should have been two babies learning to sit up, crawl, and walk. Two little boys reaching birthdays together.

Instead, Ethan lived only eleven weeks. And during those eleven weeks, there were repeated opportunities for adults and institutions to recognize that he was being hurt.

Ethan’s Story

Ethan and his twin brother Lucas were born on February 21, 2012.

Within weeks, Ethan began suffering injuries.

When Ethan was approximately four weeks old, his father became frustrated while changing his diaper. Gordon later admitted that he grabbed Ethan by his upper left arm, twisted it, and pushed it backward.

Ethan suffered a broken arm.

His mother contacted his pediatrician the following day. Ethan was examined and referred for additional medical evaluation.

The explanation given for the injury was that Ethan's arm had become caught between the slats of his crib while he was being picked up with his blankets.

The fracture was not reported to child protection authorities as suspected abuse.

It would not be the last injury Ethan suffered.

During his short life, numerous medical professionals and caregivers had contact with him. Additional bruising and injuries appeared.

After Ethan died, investigators discovered evidence of repeated trauma, including healing rib fractures, head injuries, bruising to his upper arms, and an ankle fracture.

Concerns existed beyond Ethan himself.

Reports involving his older sister included allegations of extensive bruising, inadequate supervision, and other possible abuse.

By late April, someone contacted Maine's child abuse hotline specifically reporting concerns that Ethan and his siblings were being abused.

On May 3, a Child Protective Services worker visited the family's home in Arundel. Ethan was examined during that visit.

The preliminary determination was that Ethan and the other children were safe in their parents' care.

Two days later, on May 5, Gordon was caring for Ethan and Lucas while Christina was at work.

Ethan was crying.

Gordon became overwhelmed and angry. He later admitted picking his infant son up by the head and throwing him into a recliner.

Ethan suffered catastrophic brain injuries.

He was transported to the hospital and ultimately taken to Maine Medical Center in Portland.

For three days, Ethan remained on life support.

His injuries could not be survived.

On May 8, 2012, Ethan was taken off life support and died.

He was eleven weeks old.

His death was ruled a homicide.

Warning Signs and System Failures

Ethan's story contains an extraordinary number of warning signs for a child who lived for only eleven weeks.

Before his death, Maine's child abuse hotline had received numerous reports concerning Ethan or children in his household.

Some reports were screened out without investigation. Others involved allegations concerning Ethan's older sister.

Ethan himself suffered a broken arm when he was only about four weeks old.

A fracture in a baby who could not crawl or walk was a significant warning sign.

Multiple medical professionals became aware of the injury. Yet the fracture was not reported to Child Protective Services as suspected abuse.

Ethan continued living in the same home.

Additional injuries accumulated. He appeared at daycare with deep red bruising on his arm.

Later reviews found evidence of injuries in various stages of healing.

Nurses, doctors, and other mandated reporters had opportunities to recognize that something was wrong. Several did not report what they saw.

Then came the direct report to Child Protective Services.

On April 30, 2012, an anonymous caller reported suspected physical abuse involving the family.

A CPS worker visited the home on May 3. The family knew the worker was coming.

After the visit, the agency made a preliminary determination that Ethan was safe.

Two days later, Gordon inflicted the injuries that would kill him.

After Ethan's death, Maine reviewed how child protection authorities and medical professionals had handled his case.

The review found failures extending beyond a single person or agency.

Several mandated medical reporters were found to have failed to report obvious or suspected signs of child abuse.

A visiting nurse who had encountered Ethan before his death ultimately surrendered her nursing license following disciplinary proceedings related to the failure to report his injuries.

The medical board reviewing Ethan's pediatrician did not impose formal discipline, although it issued a letter of guidance.

No state Child Protective Services employee was disciplined as a result of Ethan's death.

Ethan had been alive for only eleven weeks.

In that extraordinarily short time, he had suffered a broken arm, bruising, and other injuries.

Reports had been made. Medical professionals had seen him. Child welfare authorities had visited his home.

Three days before Ethan died, the system responsible for protecting him decided he was safe.

He was not.

JUSTICE FOR ETHAN

Gordon Collins-Faunce was arrested after the fatal assault.

He initially faced an elevated aggravated assault charge while Ethan remained alive. After Ethan died, prosecutors pursued a murder charge.

Gordon eventually pleaded guilty to domestic violence manslaughter.

On October 30, 2013, he was sentenced to 30 years in prison, with all but 20 years suspended.

He was also ordered to serve 14 years of probation following his release.

 

Gordon Collins-Faunce

Relationship to Ethan: Father

Conviction: Domestic violence manslaughter

Sentence: 30 years, with all but 20 years suspended, followed by 14 years of probation

FOREVER REMEMBERED

Only days after Ethan died, people gathered in Arundel for a candlelight vigil.

Family and friends lit candles and spoke about the baby they had lost. They signed a child's helium balloon and released it into the sky.

Ethan's mother called him her cuddle bug.

Those are the pieces of Ethan that deserve to exist beside the reports documenting everything that went wrong.

He was not a broken arm. He was not a CPS file. He was not a collection of missed warning signs.

He was Ethan.

He was Lucas's twin brother.

The two boys entered the world together on February 21, 2012.

Only one was allowed to continue growing.

Ethan should have learned to recognize his twin brother's face. They should have crawled across the same floor and learned to walk around the same time.

There should have been photographs in which people had to explain which twin was which.

There should have been birthdays where two names were written on the cake.

Instead, Ethan's life became a case studied because so many adults encountered warning signs during such an impossibly short period of time.

After his death, agencies reviewed their decisions. Professional boards examined what medical workers had done.

Investigative journalists reconstructed the reports that had been made.

People debated who could have stopped what happened.

Ethan never needed those answers after his death.

He needed someone to recognize the danger while he was alive.

Eleven weeks should have been the beginning of Ethan Thomas Henderson's life.

Instead, it became all of it.

Abuse Angels remembers Ethan Thomas Henderson.

Remembered. Honored. Never Forgotten.

Search
Your cart is empty

Select Currency

{CC} - {CN}